Tuesday, October 7, 2014

Language Experiment

I knew not being able to speak to someone during a conversation would be difficult, but I didn't realize just how challenging it would be. It was fairly easy to answer my boyfriend's questions by nodding, smiling, shrugging, etc. But when I wanted to ask a simple question, if he had seen a certain t.v. show on Netflix, my mind drew a blank. How on earth was I going to ask a question like that when I can't speak and I wasn't able to just point to the picture of it? (I wasn't at home and didn't have access to the internet) I never did figure it out, and most of the conversation ended up mostly being him asking questions and me answering them.
As the conversation went on, I noticed my boyfriend slowly start to talk more slowly and loudly, which he didn't even realize he was doing. Even though he knew I completely understood everything he was saying, since I wasn't able to speak in the same way he unconsciously thought I didn't know the language, and that he should speak slower/louder so I could better understand it. This was a very interesting result and I did not expect it at all.
A culture with a developed, extensive, symbolic language would be much better at communicating complex ideas; there are so many different things to explore and talk about that it would be impossible to do so without such a language. It seems like the culture with this type of language looks down upon those cultures without it, seeing them as inferior and possibly even uncivilized. In our own culture, children often have difficulty speaking the language, as they simply don't have the vocabulary necessary to express their ideas. Adults often talk down to them and oversimplify subjects because they assume that because of their apparent lack of language skills they aren't very intelligent. But there has been several times when my own little sister (who is 9) has surprised a group of adults by saying something so profound and out of the blue that we have just stared at her; no one could believe that children really are intelligent and may just have difficulty expressing it.

Initially I thought the second part of the experiment (not using any hand signals or body motions, etc) would be pretty easy. I even teased my boyfriend because he always "talks" with his hands and I thought it would be really difficult for him. But I accidentally motioned with my hand after about 2 minutes. I didn't even realize I had done it, it was such an absentminded movement. I said oops, laughed it off, then did it again a minute later. After that I put my hands in my pockets so I wouldn't use them. All was fine until, as we were walking through the grocery aisle of Target, I pointed at something with my foot! So even though I never use my foot to point at something, it was such an important action that I subconsciously switched to using my foot in order to communicate.
Other than my boyfriend laughing a lot when I messed up, I didn't notice too much of a reaction to my limitations. It was slightly more difficult to communicate, and if I wanted to point something out it would take a lot longer to describe what and where it was. But I found not being able to speak much more difficult than not being able to move.
This showed that signs are surprisingly very important in communication, although we may not realize it.
I have known a few people who can't read body language very well; someone may be obviously angry or frustrated with someone else, and that person doesn't realize it and continues to do whatever is bothering them. Not being able to read body language can cause confusion,tension, etc. It is very beneficial to be able to read it, as it can make communication much more efficient and easier when describing where something is or what it looks like. I honestly cannot think of a situation where it would be useful to not read body language.

2 comments:

  1. "How on earth was I going to ask a question like that when I can't speak and I wasn't able to just point to the picture of it? "

    :-) Good insight. Yes, without symbolic language, you are relegated to a passive role in the conversation, answering questions but not initiating topics.

    "As the conversation went on, I noticed my boyfriend slowly start to talk more slowly and loudly, which he didn't even realize he was doing."

    Great observation! Yes, this is a common reaction by people and it makes no sense. You see this a lot with people who are blind or have other disability that don't impact their ability to understand spoken language. People see "disability" and assume that will negatively impact their ability to understand language. I'm not sure I understand the reason for this.

    It may be because you were moving around while you did the second experiment and your boyfriend was distracted, but often partners become very uncomfortable with Part 2. Occasionally, partners will react angrily and even walk out. You were lucky with just laughter! But is it worth asking why people can react so strongly to a lack of body language. What is missing in the conversation that is provided by body language?

    There are specific groups of people who are known for having great difficulty reading body language. Can you think of any?

    For the last point, are there any circumstances where body language might mislead you? Can it be misinterpreted? Do all cultures use the same system of body language?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello Caitlin,
    I just read your post and I really liked what you said about children being able to understand things that surround them but not being able to express it as clearly as adults. I find it amazing how as adults we tend to talk down to children when we at one point were children perceive things even better than adults. Children absorb things very fast and I think that adults should stop talking down to kids which does them no good it is better to talk to children as you would any other person as this will help them become more self-sufficient in expressing themselves.

    ReplyDelete