Tuesday, September 23, 2014

The Piltdown Hoax

The Piltdown Hoax occurred in Piltdown, England when Charles Dawson claimed to have found skeletal remains of an unknown human ancestor in 1912. Dawson found more remains and brought them to Arthur Woodward, the head of the geological department of the British Natural History Museum. They continued to find more remains; but new findings ended with his death.
Scientists (in general) believed in the hoax for nearly 40 years, until advances in fossil dating were used to find that the skull was from a medieval human and the jaw from a 500 year old orangutan. They also used a microscope and found scratches on the teeth, which showed that they had been filed down to imitate a human’s teeth; the teeth actually belonged to a chimpanzee. In addition, more and more fossils were found in the 40 year span since the first “discovery” which didn't match up with the Piltdown remains, and broke the continuity of human evolution. Because these scientists began to question and double check Dawson’s findings, instead of immediately believing him, they were able to find that they were untrue. However, many contemporary scientists had already believed that the skull was actually from a modern human, the jaw from a fossilized ape or orangutan and had been stained to imitate age. It is still unclear who exactly orchestrated the hoax, but the main suspect is Charles Dawson.
I believe the main faults of Dawson and any other scientists involved was too much ambition; they wanted to be recognized, especially by the scientific world. Some may have participated in order to further their own personal theories. I don't think it would be possible to remove these or other faults in scientists, and I don't think I would want to. It is good for scientists to have ambition and want to prove their theories, as long as they follow the scientific method and don't warp the facts to fit their theories if they don't turn out correct.
There is an important lesson to be found in the Piltdown Hoax; never blindly trust anything someone tells you, even if they seem reputable. Always find out the facts for yourself and make your own judgements. This applies not only to science, but to everyday instances involving politics, news, etc.

Wednesday, September 17, 2014

Comparing Primates

Lemurs live in the forests of Madagascar and other nearby islands off the coast of Africa; they are also the only primates found on these islands, and therefore have little competition for resources. They are mostly arboreal (live in trees), but some are more terrestrial. Many are vertical clingers and leapers (launch off a tree or branch with strong back legs and land upright on another branch), and use their long bushy tails to help them balance while jumping to and from branches (but not to grab onto branches like many related species.)




Lemurs that are mostly vertical clingers and leapers hop sideways when travelling on the ground (which is both funny and adorable in my opinion).




Some of the arboreal and the terrestrial species are quadrupeds (walk on all four limbs).


Not only are lemurs the only primates on these islands, but they are more or less the only arboreal species as well; this caused them to evolve and fill the niche normally occupied by animals such as squirrels, etc. Their locomotion allows them to easily reach nuts, fruits, etc in their environment.




Spider Monkeys are “New World” Monkeys; ie they live in Central and South America, in the tropical rainforests. They are arboreal and quadrupedal, as well as semibrachiators (they can also move by using their long hook-like hands and long arms to swing from branch to branch).




Their tails function as a “third hand” and are used in their locomotion to grasp branches; they also allow them to hang from branches, causing the Spider Monkey to not only exert less effort to support itself, but also to free both hands in order to gather and eat more fruit.





Baboons are “Old World” Monkeys, and live in Southern Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. They can be found in tropical jungles, semiarid deserts and in snowy mountains in northern Japan. They are quadrupedal and mostly terrestrial, and live in the trees at night. Their limbs are more proportionate, allowing them to be suited a wide variety of environments, instead of specializing in brachiation or leaping for arboreal locomotion, like the Spider Monkey or Lemurs.





Gibbons are found in tropical and subtropical rainforests in southern Asia (Indonesia, Vietnam, Myanmar, etc). They are mostly arboreal and are the most brachiated of the primates; their arms are so long that when walking of the ground they move bipedally with their arms raised at their sides.




Gibbons have powerful shoulders and long curved fingers that they use to swing and move from tree to tree, as well as for hanging from branches while they eat. Their wrists also have a ball and socket joint, which reduces the energy used and the stress on the shoulder while swinging.






Chimpanzees live only in Africa’s tropical forests and savannas. The different climates range from constant humidity and temperature to arid areas with fluctuating humidity and temperature.




Their arms are slightly longer than their legs, and are mostly quadrupedal (and walk on their knuckles like gorillas) unless they are carrying something, where they temporarily walk bipedally.




They can also brachiate (using opposable thumbs and big toes to grip branches), and are both arboreal and terrestrial.




Due to the differences in their climate, chimps have adapted to being able to acclimate to changing environments (quadrupedal in savannas, brachiate in forests, etc).


The environment has a major effect on how traits are expressed; this is obvious when looking at the difference between just lemurs and every other species of primates. Lemurs were isolated on the islands of Madagascar and adapted to fill the arboreal niche; they look completely different and have different traits from chimps, bonobos, gibbons, etc; they are  the only ones of the groups observed here that are vertical clingers and leapers, while the other groups have similar locomotion (most are quadrupedal or brachiate, or both).

Thursday, September 11, 2014

Homologies vs Analogies



As you can see from the picture above, cats’ and humans’ forearms are very similar in structure; the humerus, radius, ulna and carpals of both species are almost identical. However, cats don't have thumbs like humans do, although they do have claws. Cats’ metacarpals are thicker and more vertical, while their phalanges are more horizontal (and also thicker). The function of humans’ arms are to hold, carry, push, etc objects, while cats’ forearms function pretty much the same as their back legs. The common ancestor of cats and humans was a placental mammal; all placental mammals, from bats to whales to to bears to humans, have forearms with similar structures.




Sharks and dolphins have similar body structures (body plans), and while it may seem like homologous at first, it is in fact analogous. Their dorsal fins and torpedo shaped bodies, as you can see from the picture, have similar structure and function (in both species, they help it move better in the water).
But these traits are analogous; dolphins are mammals while sharks are fish. Sharks have been around much longer than mammals, who evolved later. If you go back far enough you can find a common ancestor of sharks and dolphins. This common ancestor did in fact have the traits for these fins and this shape, but the tetrapod groups that later evolved lost those traits. Eventually, whales and dolphins “re-evolve” those traits again.

Wednesday, September 3, 2014