Thursday, September 11, 2014

Homologies vs Analogies



As you can see from the picture above, cats’ and humans’ forearms are very similar in structure; the humerus, radius, ulna and carpals of both species are almost identical. However, cats don't have thumbs like humans do, although they do have claws. Cats’ metacarpals are thicker and more vertical, while their phalanges are more horizontal (and also thicker). The function of humans’ arms are to hold, carry, push, etc objects, while cats’ forearms function pretty much the same as their back legs. The common ancestor of cats and humans was a placental mammal; all placental mammals, from bats to whales to to bears to humans, have forearms with similar structures.




Sharks and dolphins have similar body structures (body plans), and while it may seem like homologous at first, it is in fact analogous. Their dorsal fins and torpedo shaped bodies, as you can see from the picture, have similar structure and function (in both species, they help it move better in the water).
But these traits are analogous; dolphins are mammals while sharks are fish. Sharks have been around much longer than mammals, who evolved later. If you go back far enough you can find a common ancestor of sharks and dolphins. This common ancestor did in fact have the traits for these fins and this shape, but the tetrapod groups that later evolved lost those traits. Eventually, whales and dolphins “re-evolve” those traits again.

3 comments:

  1. Hello Caitlin,
    I just read your post for this week’s assignment and I thought that you did a wonderful job with it. I love the pictures that you provided which were very detailed on the trait that you found in common with both sets of species. The most interesting information that I found was that dolphins are actually mammals while sharks are fish. I had a very biased idea that because they both were sea creatures that they would both be considered fish. For your homologous set I was wondering if you could explain to me what exactly that cat uses his forearms for a little more specifically. This will help me understand why a cat does not have an opposable thumb as humans do.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good discussion and explanation of the homologous traits. You also did a good job of showing evidence for common descent of these traits.

    Excellent explanation for the reasons why your analogous pairings are indeed analogous, even though the common ancestor did possess this trait and passed it onto sharks. That can be difficult to explain. Well done.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Caitlin,
    I really enjoyed reading your post. The pictures were very detailed and helpful.
    Susan

    ReplyDelete