Jean-Baptiste Lamarck was a French naturalist who, although ridiculed by many of his contemporaries, made several contributions to the theory of evolution and the field of biology. In fact, he coined both the term biology itself, as well as coining "invertebrates" and adding many new classifications for them. His Disuse Theory attempted to explain the process of evolution, even if it isn't exactly correct. He believed that when the environment changed, so would the actions of the animals in it. According to Lamarck, animals would increase or decrease the use of certain body parts, and over time the continued and different use of those parts would be modified, or even disappear if unused. These alterations would make the animal better suited to the environment, with more access to resources, and would pass those acquired traits on to its offspring. This is genetically incorrect as we now know (traits must be heritable and not acquired to pass onto offspring), but still relevant as it emphasizes the importance of the environment in natural selection.
Darwin was exposed to Lamarck's ideas while studying medicine at Edinburg. Previously Darwin had been a more or less average student, but it was his time at Edinburg that caused him to be more interested and intellectual. And although Lamarck's ideas were not genetically correct, he was on the right track; individuals with better traits for an environment are more suited to that environment and pass those traits on to their offspring. That is the backbone natural selection. Without Lamarck, it is possible that Darwin would never have become so interested in science and evolution. And if he had, it may have taken him longer to develop his theory and Alfred Wallace may have received the credit instead.
The church was vehemently opposed to ideas of evolution, as it contradicted their belief of God's creation. Darwin was very hesitant to publish his ideas of natural selection and evolution because they were so controversial. But after he received Wallace's paper describing his own theory of natural selection, Darwin quickly wrote a paper of his ideas. Both papers were read at the Linnean Society of London, but they were practically ignored, until Darwin published On the Origin of Species, and the scientific community largely began to accept his theory of evolution. However, the church and public opinion still opposed his ideas, and to this day have caused residual skepticism of the theory.
Sources: www.ucmp.berkely.edu/history/lamarck.html
Sources: www.ucmp.berkely.edu/history/lamarck.html
Good job both discussing the differences between Lamarck's and Darwin's theories and then highlighting the similarities to show how Lamarck may have made a positive influence on Darwin's work. Good explanation.
ReplyDeleteI agree that it is possible that Darwin might not have developed his theory or just taken longer. Interesting idea that Wallace might have received all the credit without Lamarck! However, I hesitate giving any scientist too much credit for the work of another, making them indispensable.
Yes, Darwin hesitated to publish, but he hesitated for more than 20 years. That is significant. Can you be more specific about what concerns might have led Darwin to delay? What repercussions might he and his family experienced as a result of publishing?
To be honest, there really wasn't as much objection as Darwin expected or feared. Opposition came from religious (not scientific) sources many years later in America. The rest of Europe tends to wonder why America has so many problems with evolutionary theory. We should be embarrassed!
Good source.